Bed Bug Epidemic

" The Bed Bug Epidemic is a global phenomenon according to a 2010 survey by the University of Kentucky and the NPMA (National Pest Management Association). The study points out that bed bug exterminators are receiving more and more calls about bed bugs, with most calls concentrated in urban and suburban areas. Reasons for the growth in bed bug complaints include international travel, the lack of easy to implement treatment methods, and a lack of education on how to protect yourself against a infestation.The same survey indicates that the majority of bedbug exterminators believe that bedbugs are more difficult to treat than termites, ants and cockroaches. "  

The History of the BedBug Epidemic

Bed bugs have been a plague for man kind for centuries (even back to the last ice age in Middle East caves - 10,000 years ago). They are even referenced by Aristotle. Before WWII, they were a constant problem in homes, which is the origin of the rhyme "don't let the bed bugs bite."

Further proof of a past worldwide bed bug epidemic is that every language has a word to described the insect. In middle English, they are referred to as bugge, which means ghost or wraith. This makes sense since bedbugs usually come out at night. 

bed bug epidemic
Bed Bug Epidemic
Title page from book on bedbugs, about 1730
(Source:Usinger 1966)

In Sweden, the largest pest control company is named after the bed bug, Cimex. In England in the 18th Century, "professional exterminators concocted secret formulas to destroy bugs" (Usinger 1966).  At the time, there was a company that described itself as "bug-destroyers to Her Majesty and the Royal Family."  People often switched to iron beds instead of wood, since iron is not as attractive as wood to bed bugs.

In the late 19th century (1875), the pesticide DDT was used to kill all kinds of insects including bedbugs, cockroaches, fleas and mosquitoes. This was the primary method for killing bed bugs in the 1940's and 1950's.  It's use declined as bed bug resistance to the insecticide increased.  The insecticide was banned in 1972 due to a link to cancer in humans.

Insect treatments that replaced DDT for insects such as cockroaches, did not kill bedbugs, allowing the bed bug population to grow.  Even if DDT were allowed to be used today as a response to the bedbug problem, it would not work as a recent University of Kentucky study on Bed Bug resistance (pdf download) showed that 95% of bed bugs in New York are now resistant to the insecticide.  It would be more effective in other areas.

In the early 20th century (1901-2000), reports in London said 4 million people suffered from bed bug bites and 1/3 of the dwellings in Stockholm were thought to be infested (IPM Practitioner 4/2007).

Today's Bed Bug Epidemic

The current bed bug epidemic began in the 1990's as International travel increased combined with the ability of bed bugs to not be affected by insecticides used to kill other insects.  

Places that cater to transient populations such as dormitories, hotels, halfway houses, summer camps, airport lounges, conference centers, restaurants and temporary shelters are at risk for bedbugs.

Bed bug infestations are rapidly increasing in number and are a worldwide problem. For example, in Australia, between  1999 and 2006 there was exponential growth in the number of new infestations equating to an extraordinary increase of 4,500% (Doggett and Russell, 2007). 

In the United States, according to the NPMA, the average bed bug exterminator receives 1 to 2 bed bug related calls per week (2010) vs. prior years where they would receive 1 to 2 calls a year. Most bedbug infestations are reported in urban and suburban areas, as well as other places where their are transient populations such as hotels, dormitories and hospitals.

In New York, the city that is considered to be on the verge of a bed bug epidemic, the growth in complaints is alarming:

FY 2008 FY 2009 FY 2010 % Increase FY09-FY10
Total Bed Bug Inquiries 20,019 25,613 34,123 33.2%
New York City Bed Bug Epidemic
Bed Bug Related Calls to NYC 311 Information Hotline 
(Source: NewYork vs. Bedbugs)

bed bug epidemic
Picture Bed Bug Biting Skin

Why is Bed Bug Treatment so Difficult?

Bed bugs are very resilient and difficult to control, even for professionals. They are adept at hiding and have rapidly developed resistance to many pesticides. For example, as mentioned above, DDT, a banned chemical credited with practically ending any past bed bug epidemic in the Unites States, has been shown in lab test to only kill 5% of bed bugs found in New York City, with the rest completely resistant (University of Kentucky). 

Bed bug control requires a treatment strategy utilizing multiple chemical and non-chemical techniques. Bed Bug pesticides are often combined with other methods such as vacuuming, steam and diatomaceous earth to address an infestation.

What are Current Methods of Bed Bug Management?

Ending today's bed bug epidemic is difficult given the need to use multiple methods of bed bug control instead of one method, such as the use of DDT.

Fighting a bed bug epidemic or problem involves multiple methods including:

Bed Bug Management Method Details
Laundry Linens and clothes washed in hot water followed by 20 to 30 minutes in the dryer will be bed bug free. Items should be stored after washing in a bed bug proof container or Ziploc Big Bag.
Bed Bug Sniffing Dog Dogs are effective at locating bed bug infestations. They cost $10,000 to purchase and can several hundred dollars for an in-home inspection. Bed Bug dogs are 98% accurate, but can falsely detect bedbugs.
Mattress and Box Spring Encasements The approach traps bed bugs and bed bug eggs that were missed during treatment.
Bed Bug Traps Carbon Dioxide based bed bug traps and climbup interceptors can trap bedbugs or help to keep bedbugs from getting up on the bed.
Vacuuming Helps to remove some bed bugs from the room. Crevice tool can help get into tight spaces. Must be used with other methods.
Steam A hand held steamer can generate the heat needed to kill bedbugs and bed bug eggs. Often used before the application of bed bug pesticides.
Thermal Remediation To treat luggage a portable heat chamber called a PackTite is used. For single rooms, homes or buildings, portable heaters are used to raise  temperatures to the required levels so that lethal heat can penetrate all items in the room including walls.  Very effective. It costs approximately $800 to $2000 to treat an apartment.
Bed Bug Pesticides Usually a combination of knock down (kills bed bugs and bed bug eggs on contact) and residual products (provide protection for several weeks) are used. Highly effective bedbug sprays include the knock down products Sterifab and Bedlam, and the residual spray Phantom. The EPA in the United States has a bed bug pesticide search tool.
Freezing Carbon Dioxide Spray (Dry Ice) A carbon dioxide spray is used by some bed bug exterminators to kill bedbugs by freezing them.

Does Temperature Effect Bedbugs?

Temperature does effect the rate at which they multiply, with ideal human temperatures matching the ideal temperatures for bedbugs. Bedbugs can move from egg to adult in 21 days at 86F (30C).  At lower temperatures, 68F (18C), the can develop from egg to adult in 120 days.  Their activity slows down between in temperatures lower than 55F (13C) and 59F (15C).  However, bed bugs can adapt to cold weather and be active at 45F (7C).

Heat at temperatures between 111F and 113F (44C to 45C) will kill bed bugs and bed bug eggs.

How are Bed Bugs Spread?

Bed bugs need to be carried from one location to the next. They do not fly and they do not leap. They crawl about the speed of an ant from one object to the next and tend to not move more than 100 feet in any direction. Many researchers suspect that global travelers are the reason why we are seeing the current bed bug epidemic. A traveler that stays in an infested hotel room would bring back bed bugs hiding in their luggage. When the luggage is brought home the infestation spreads. This is why bed bugs are found at both expensive hotels and inexpensive hotels. Places where people constantly move in and out, such as hospitals, apartments etc. are particularly susceptible to bed bugs. Lower income apartments have seen rapid growth of the problem because residents are more likely to purchase or pick up used mattresses and furniture. For example a mattress that is discarded due to bed bugs could easily be picked up by another home owner, thus spreading the bed bug problem.

In most cases, people are completely unaware that they are bringing home bed bugs hidden furniture, clothing, bedding, and luggage. In other cases they move through openings in walls to adjoining apartments.  In fact, there is a 20% chance that bed bugs will move from an infested apartment  to an adjacent apartment and a 7% chance that they will move to an apartment over or below the infested apartment.

Are Bed Bug Bites a Sure Sign of an Infestation?

Also, it is believed that 70% of the population shows no reaction to bed bug bites. Since bites are often the first noticeable sign of a bed bug infestation an infestation can be allowed to grow unchecked and spread to other areas of buildings. These individuals can then carry bed bugs to other locations such as theaters, hospitals, social service offices and other locations where they hitch a ride on another person who then carries the bedbugs to another home.

bed bug epidemic
Picture Bed Bugs Bites on Arm

Do Bed Bugs Spread Disease?

Bed bugs do not spread disease. However, in allergic individuals the bed bug bites, when itched can become infected. A very small percentage of individuals can experience asthma or shock from the bites. A recent study (11/2010) has indicated that in hospitals there may be a connection between bed bugs and the spread of the MRSA infection in patients. This is a dangerous skin disease that is difficult to treat.

According to the NPMA study, bed bugs due lead to distress. According to the study, 99% of clients who have had bed bugs were “upset and concerned” and 77% said such customers were “very upset and concerned.”  

Top Bed Bug Cities in the United States

According to Terminix, the top U.S. based on bed bug calls to the company include: 

  1. New York
  2. Philadelphia
  3. Detroit
  4. Cincinnati
  5. Chicago
  6. Denver
  7. Columbus, Ohio
  8. Dayton, Ohio
  9. Washington, D.C.
  10. Los Angeles
  11. Boston
  12. Indianapolis
  13. Louisville, Ky.
  14. Cleveland
  15. Minneapolis, Minn.

Ohio was the single state with most bed bug related calls., Philadelphia and Detroit were also mentioned as having a significant number of calls.

Bed Bug Identification

Bed bugs are often confused with other insects such as young cockroaches and bat bugs.  To be sure, bring a sample bed bug to a cooperative or county extension office.  Call ahead to make sure that they have a staff entomologist (insect expert).

The Future of the Current Bed Bug Epidemic

There is not clear resolution to the growing bed bug epidemic. Many cities and states are just starting to adjust laws that govern landlord/tenant rights to include bed bugs.  Others are using education to warn residents regarding bed bug protection methods.

Bed bug pest control firms are quickly getting up to speed on the latest chemical and mechanical methods of bed bug removal. The future however, is largely based on the ability to come up with either an organic or pesticide based method of killing bedbugs that provides lasting protection against these insects.  Until then, the worldwide bed bug epidemic will continue to be a problem.

References for Bed Bug Epidemic:


National Pest Management Association

Connecticut Agricultural Experiment Station

Battling Bed Bugs in the USA
Potter, Michael F; Haynes, Kenneth F.; Romero, Alvaro
University of Kentucky

Ask a Question or Share Your Bed Bug Experience With Others

Do you have a question or great story about bed bugs? Share it!

[ ? ]

Upload A Bed Bug Picture (optional)[ ? ]

 

Click here to upload more images (optional)

Author Information (optional)

To receive credit as the author, enter your information below.

(first or full name)

(e.g., City, State, Country)

Submit Your Contribution

 submission guidelines.


(You can preview and edit on the next page)


     


Bed Bug Search





[?] Subscribe To This Site

XML RSS
follow us in feedly
Add to My Yahoo!



Please Click the +1 to let others know that this is a quality site




Click here to learn more